Is dying at home best for everyone?


Photo by Lillian Nelson/Freeimages

In recent years, a growing movement has embraced the concept of dying at home, versus a hospital or nursing home. In general, I support the idea, after my father had a difficult death in a skilled nursing facility while I was 1,300 miles away. But having experienced the challenges of being a primary caregiver for my mother, who died at home, I also understand just how traumatic such a death can be for family members. The latter is a viewpoint that is not often discussed.

Ann Brenoff, who covers aging topics for Huffington Post, interviewed me last week to discuss the potential consequences for the family caregiver when a loved one chooses to die at home. The article, When Loved Ones Die At Home, Family Caregivers Pay The Price, offers an important perspective on the subject. The article references my 2015 essay, Why dying at home is not all it’s cracked up to be. Brenoff discusses how financial concerns are behind the government’s desire for people to die at home. While it’s cheaper for people to die at home, caregivers pay the ultimate price.

In many cases, family caregivers shoulder the burden of care duties. Some have to quit their jobs or reduce work hours, impacting their financial status. Chronic stress can affect their own health. The emotional toll can be devastating.

To achieve a good death at home standard, we must offer greater support to family caregivers.

There are pros and cons to everything, including dying at home. The more we learn about each other’s caregiving experiences, the better informed we will be when we face a family health crisis or end-of-life care situation.



Filed under Memories

2 responses to “Is dying at home best for everyone?

  1. The reality is in some cases, like my mother’s, it is impossible. She lived with us, incapacitated, for over nine years. Luckily she had some long term insurance to pay for caregivers. Nevertheless at some point, the wonderful woman who helped her in so many ways came to me and said my mother needed to go to a nursing home. It was dangerous to have her at home, both for herself and for caregivers. I felt guilty at first, of course, but I am so glad we moved her. She was happier having me visit and died peacefully nine months later.

    • I totally agree. The same was true with my father’s dementia. His disease progressed to the point where he was a safety risk to himself and to my mother, who was caring for him by herself. The memory care center wasn’t perfect, but he was safe.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s