Tag Archives: SNL

SNL’s ‘Sister’ skit sparks a national conversation about family caregiving

It’s rare when the subject of caregiving goes viral, but SNL managed to do so recently with its skit, “Sister.”

If you haven’t seen the skit yet, it’s a biting but accurate portrayal of how many families deal with providing care for an aging parent: one sibling (usually a sister) ends up responsible for the bulk of hands-on care duties, while the other siblings go on with their lives, contributing either sporadically or not at all. The skit focuses on the gender disparity, which is one of the more common situations. A sister is expected to be the natural caregiver, while the brother may donate money or other resources but is not expected to make the same level of life-altering sacrifices, such as quit a job and move across the country to care for an aging parent. While as an only child I can’t relate to the sibling dynamics, that part still resonated with me because when my mother fell ill, I had to quit my new job and move across the country to care for her, as there was no one else available to be her caregiver.

But in the many conversations I’ve had with women serving as family caregivers, the lack of support from other siblings often includes both brothers and sisters. These caregivers opened up to me after learning I was an only child, and shared that they often felt like an only child because it felt like the caregiving burden was entirely on their shoulders. This led to bitter sibling disputes, sometimes permanently fracturing families.

Another portion of the skit also hit home with me. That’s the part where the son who’s not providing the daily care gets to maintain his friendly son-father relationship, while the sister has to be the rule-enforcing caregiver and housekeeper. I experienced something similar to this with my mother, who would put on a happy, lighthearted front when we were out in public, but was critical of the care I was providing her at home.

Mom and I on a good day.

When dementia is involved, there’s another layer to complicate dynamics. As in the above scenario, people in the early stages of dementia may be able to hide symptoms in certain situations, and for adult children who rarely visit, the cognitive changes may not be as noticeable as to the sibling who cares for the parent on a regular basis. There may also be sibling disputes about the care options for a parent whose dementia is progressing to the point where they can no longer live independently.

I published a book about being a reluctant caregiver and since my own challenging caregiving experience, I’ve been an advocate for those who face similar situations. People who don’t naturally have an affinity for caregiving are not bad people. It’s not selfish to establish boundaries; sometimes its necessary to protect one’s mental and emotional health. What is wrong is allowing one sibling to take on the bulk of caregiving duties without having a candid conversation about expectations and offering adequate, meaningful support.

It shouldn’t take a comedy skit to propel family caregiving issues into the national spotlight, but the fact that so many caregivers could relate and felt seen should not be ignored. Caregiver advocates should take advantage of the moment by pushing lawmakers to enact legislation that offers real support for families facing a health crisis. I’m still a fan of the care corps concept. No family member should have to give up their lives to support an aging parent’s health needs. Sibling relationship shouldn’t be forever destroyed due to bitterness and anger over lopsided care arrangements.

For more discussions about the “Sisters” SNL skit, check out these resources:

An ‘SNL’ skit exposed America’s elder care plan: daughters

‘Sister’ Sketch from ‘SNL’ Exposes a Long-Known Truth: The Imbalance of Family Caregiving

Whether it’s ‘Sister’ or your own sister, the burden that caring for aging parents puts on women is no joke

My Brother Is The Sister In The Viral SNL Sketch

Leave a comment

Filed under Awareness & Activism, Memories